Before or After?

This could either be the best argument for Gitmo or the worst.

As for the best: Would hostilities be over for the purpose of keeping the detainees as 'enemy combatants' then length of time they deem the war to be going on?

Much like 'insane' people in the Criminal Justice system.

So the focus would have to be on some kind of Saudi or Iraqi type rehabilitation system.

As for the worst: well, that's self explanatory. Gitmo is just a terrorist factory!

Which one is it? Hell if I know.

UPDATE:
Volokh Conspiracy agrees, well in a more cynical and round about way.